To the director of the movie Gentlemen's Agreement: In my personal opinion, your way of expressing the issues of anti-semitism using the theme of "passing" is really creative. The inherent sueriority of the method of passing used as a way for investigation is that it put people into a realistic context to experience all kinds of struggles and dilemmas a minority may fae under various circumstances.   However, in my personal point of view, rather than using an actual "bystander" in the anti-semitism issue instead of an aJew makes the information conveyed in the movie seem to be like a "second hand source"--any creator of novels or films cannot discern the true feelings of a certain character without actually describing his or her feelings from his or her point of view. On the other hand, the way of expressing themes in the movie seem to be like a disorderly hodgepodge: emotions between family, love affaires, social issues... If a piece of film is piled up with more than two themes, it's inevitably going to be confusing. Last but not the least, the way the main theme of passing for investigation on anti-semitism came up too suddenly for the audiences to acutally perceive it in a proper way.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Letter to Claudia Rankine

Dear Claudia Rankine,   I really liked the way you formatted your book by telling different stories from the perspective of a person of color or on the behalf of another person of color. I found it interesting how the first chapter (and others throughout the book) were written in the second person. It is a very unusual writing style, but I found it an effective way to articulate your message, as the readers can better understand the discrimination people of color face and the emotions that follow. I'm interested in knowing how you came up with this method of portrayal.  A story I found especially captivating was the one about Serena Williams. I thought I "knew" about the discrimination she faced as a black women in a traditionally white sport, but I never realized how it was evident through refereeing and increasing progressed through the years. I also didn't realize the effect it had on her emotional attitude on the court, and as a result, I have much more...
Read more

The Catch-22 of Visibility

Dear Claudia Rankine, A major theme of your masterpiece, Citizen , is visibility: how much space are you allowed to take up in every situation in which you are the only minority there? How about in the public consciousness? Even a sigh or a moan, those sounds which feel to you most uncontrollable and natural reflections of your dire circumstance, feel too loud. For some African-Americans, invisibility, a kind of "keep your head down" mentality, serves as the best strategy to get ahead. Try to take the higher ground and not fly into a fit of rage at every injustice. Unfortunately, this can also desensitize and numb oppressed groups to everyday aggressions, those you describe so keenly with each flip of the page. To me, the most unfathomable part of your story was when you described the phenomenon of people mistaking you for other Black people. As you mention, "Apparently your own invisibility is the real problem causing her confusion." (43) I know this kind of ...
Read more

Control

Dear Claudia Rankine, Thank you for Citizen . Before even opening the book, the cover struck me as I examined the torn, limbless black hoodie, now a symbol for racial profiling and police brutality. I was reminded of Ta-Nehesi Coates who writes about the lack of control black people have other their bodies, their lives, that can be taken from them at any moment because of microagressions and racism- all down to a hoodie. A black hoodie stands in for a black man, its presence seems to alert and warn the white viewer to stand armed. Upon reading the book, I fell in love with the way you structure prose poetry- it flows through memories and emotions which are not organized neatly and clearly. You place the reader as the "you" as they explore everyday racism (also known as microaggressions) and its detrimental impact on the person; we are forced into the crippling, disorienting minds of an annoymous person. You powerfully portray how racism deteriorates the psyche of a black p...
Read more